← All work

Techno-economic analysis

Choosing the product strategy before committing to tooling

Barros & Moreira had to decide how a new range of flushing valves would cover its market: two dedicated valves, one for interior cisterns and one universal, or a single versatile valve made in versions for both. We compared the two routes on components, material, unit cost and tooling investment, before any mould was committed.

The challenge

Each route had a cost the other avoided. Two dedicated valves keep each product lean and cheap to make, but mean two product lines to tool, stock and assemble. A single valve in versions means one platform to develop and produce, but every unit carries the complexity needed for both markets. Choosing wrong would be expensive to undo once moulds were paid for, so the call had to be made early, on evidence.

What we did

  • Reverse-engineered competitor and candidate valves: counted their components, weighed the material by family and benchmarked their performance in a standard test cistern.
  • Turned each bill of materials into a unit cost and a mould investment, on the same basis for all four valves, so the two routes compared like for like.
  • Set both routes side by side in a SWOT, to weigh what the numbers miss: flexibility, development risk, logistics and market coverage.

Approach

1. Technical benchmark

We reverse-engineered competitor and candidate valves, counting their components, weighing the raw material by family and estimating production cost, then measured how each performed in a standard test cistern. That gave the four valves, two per route, a comparable bill of materials and a common performance baseline.

ComponentsPlastic32Chromed plastic5Rubber4Metal2Total43Raw-material weight (g)Plastic405Chromed plastic25Rubber27Metal3Total460
Bill of materials of the most complex valve in the comparison, the universal version of the single-valve route: 43 components and 460 g of material, broken down by material family.

2. Economic benchmark

We turned each bill of materials into a unit cost (raw material, production, mould amortisation and bought-in parts) and estimated the mould investment each valve needs, on the same basis for all four. Assembly-line cost was outside the comparison at this stage, so it compares parts and tooling. The two-product range came out ahead on every line: fewer parts, less material, a lower unit cost in both markets and less tooling per valve.

Two-product rangeSingle flexible product
Market needInteriorUniversalInteriorUniversal
Components17263243
Part weight (g)203297404460
Unit cost (index)100210201317
Tooling (index)100159172224
How to read it: each column is one valve, grouped by route. Unit cost and tooling are indexed to the cheapest valve, the interior valve of the two-product range (= 100); absolute figures are withheld for confidentiality. Tooling is each valve's own mould investment, before any sharing of moulds.

3. SWOT

Finally we set the two routes side by side in a SWOT, to weigh what the numbers miss. The single valve offered versatility, components shared between the two markets and simpler logistics with fewer moulds. Against that stood more parts, a more complex assembly line, a higher unit cost, especially for interior cisterns, and a longer, less certain development.

Outcome

The comparison let Barros & Moreira settle the range strategy early, on evidence and before committing to moulds, and the path it pointed to was adopted. Setting component count, material, unit cost and tooling side by side turned a judgement call into an explicit trade-off: leaner, cheaper valves on one side, one shared platform on the other.

Related work · Barros & MoreiraA dual-flush valve, modelled first and proven on the benchThe engineering side of the same range: how a dual-flush valve for interior cisterns was modelled, prototyped and tested against EN 14055.Read case study

Facing a similar challenge?

A first conversation takes about 30 minutes and costs nothing.